Shelf Addiction
  • Home
  • The Podcast
  • Blog
  • Monthly Read-Alongs
  • About Shelf Addiction
    • Media Kit
    • Advertising
    • Privacy Policy
  • Support Us
  • Shop
  • Tee Public Merch Store
  • Book Club Guide
  • Giveaways
Sign up for the FREE Shelf Addiction Newsletter!

Book Review | A Madness So Discreet, by Mindy McGinnis

2/29/2016

2 Comments

 
I have another book club read to review for you today. One of my many book clubs met to chat about this book a few weeks ago.  I received this title in an OwlCrate box, so I didn't even have to purchase the book! I love when happy coincidences happen.  Read on to see what I thought about A Madness So Discreet. 
Picture
Publisher: Katherine Tegen Books
Release Date: October 6, 2015 
Format: Hardcover
Pages: 376
Source: OwlCrate Box (Try OwlCrate here!)
Genre: Historical Fiction, Mystery, possibly YA
Review Date: February 29, 2016
Rating: 4 bookmarks

Synopsis: Grace Mae knows madness.

She keeps it locked away, along with her voice, trapped deep inside a brilliant mind that cannot forget horrific family secrets. Those secrets, along with the bulge in her belly, land her in a Boston insane asylum.

When her voice returns in a burst of violence, Grace is banished to the dark cellars, where her mind is discovered by a visiting doctor who dabbles in the new study of criminal psychology. With her keen eyes and sharp memory, Grace will make the perfect assistant at crime scenes. Escaping from Boston to the safety of an ethical Ohio asylum, Grace finds friendship and hope, hints of a life she should have had. But gruesome nights bring Grace and the doctor into the circle of a killer who stalks young women. Grace, continuing to operate under the cloak of madness, must hunt a murderer while she confronts the demons in her own past.


After reading and loving the two dystopian novels by McGinnis (Not a Drop to Drink, In a Handful of Dust), I wasn't sure how I'd feel about a historical fiction title. I was interested, yet a little nervous. I'm glad to report that I had nothing to worry about because McGinnis seriously flexed her author muscles!

This story starts in 1890 and takes place in both Boston and a small town in Ohio. The story centers around Grace, a young woman who is found by a doctor that dabbles in criminal profiling while in a horrible insane asylum in Boston. This book has been tied that's young adult, but personally I feel that it's an adult title. Grace under the age of 18, but just barely. The subject matter of this title is definitely 100% adult.

​​In the Boston asylum, there's a lot of mistreatment of patients going on as well as other dreadful things that are known to happen in insane asylums during that time.  Not only was it mistreatment of mentally ill, but several the patients weren't even true mentally ill people. Wives that husbands wanted to get rid, young pregnant girls hidden away in this horrible environment instead of a nunnery, and undesirable people from all walks of live.  The asylum seemed like a dumping ground for people. If you were outside societal norm then you could possibly end up in an insane asylum.

The subject was serious, some of the themes were very adult, and I think that is what helped me enjoy the story even more. I don't think I would have enjoyed it as much if it had a younger vibe.  It certainly wouldn't have been as intense. It felt like I was reading a combination of CSI and Bones. I used those two examples is because Dr. Thornhollow reminds me of how the Bones character is with with other people. ​He doesn't really relate to people in a normal way ​because  he's

Book Inspired Spotify Mini Playlist

*You need a to sign into your Spotify account to listen
constantly thinking about how to catch the killer, focusing on the next task instead of how to speak to someone. Grace is equally as smart plus she has a photographic memory.  She has the ability to think things through like no other. While she's essentially hiding her level of intelligence from the public at large while working with the doctor to keep herself from being detected, her intellect manages to shine through. Her wit and her ability to deal with Thornhollow is essential to their working relationship.  Her friends in the Ohio asylum can see that in her and it makes her friendships there even stronger  It's clear that Dr. Thornhollow needs her, and by hiding her in plain site he's able to get what he needs, an assistant and a person to help him keep grounded.  

The secondary characters were all well written as well. Grace's friends at the asylum in Ohio, her sister, her allies at the Boston asylum, as well as the doctor's sister, and various other characters rounded out this well developed cast.

If I had to critique one thing about this book, it would be the ending. The story was going strong in one direction then suddenly, around the last 20 percent of the book or so, the plot does a 180 and changes gears.  It's no longer about catching murderers anymore, but instead it's about framing someone. In my opinion, the change in the direction of the plot wasn't very smooth and it was almost unbelievable. Don't get me wrong, said framed person deserved to be framed, but it still seemed like the book totally deviated toward the end and I wanted something else. That's all I'm going to say on it without totally spoiling it for you.
This story was engaging, it was entertaining, it was dark, and I really enjoyed it. The book club enjoyed it as well. It really provided lots of passionate conversation. It lead into discussions about women's issues from that era, as well as the healthcare system, and just how things were in the 1890's in general.

If you enjoy historical fiction, a dark mystery, and stories with components of a criminal profiling, then this will be right up your alley. It's got a lot going on and it has a unique and unpredictable ending.
​Before you go, check out a few of my favorite quotes.
“I think we're all quite mad.  Some of us are just more discreet about it.”
“Sometimes the loveliest places harbor the worst monsters.”
“Sometimes the actions of the sane make no sense.” 
​
Happy Reading,
~Tamara
Get the Kindle version here: | Get the Audible version here:
2 Comments
Lekeisha link
3/1/2016 07:18:22 pm

Glad you enjoyed this one. I didn't think that I would love it as much as I did. Very memorable characters.

Reply
Lexxie @ (un)Conventional Bookviews link
3/9/2016 02:56:16 pm

I'm so glad you enjoyed A Madness So Discreet, Tamara! I found it to be really well done, too, and so awful because those things really happened! And it was so easy for a man to get rid of a female relative by stating she was mad...
I saw that you're going to BEA in May, I'm going, too! I hope we'll be able to meet :)
Have a fantastic week and happy reading.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Gain access to exclusive content!
    Picture
    Click for Shelf Addiction merch!
    Follow on Bloglovin

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Get ONE month FREE!

    ​Rating Scale: 

    Picture
    Wonderful! Loved it! Add it to your shelf!
    Picture
    ​Very good read! It's bookshelf worthy.
    Picture
    ​I liked it. Borrow it from the library or a friend.
    Picture
    I got through it...barely! If you must read it, borrow it.
    Picture
    Don't waste your time.

    Picture

    Currently Reading

    Somebody I Used to Know
    Hidden Bodies

    Follow on Bloglovin

    Read the Printed Word!
    Picture

    DISCLAIMER 
    All affiliate links used on this site are links which I will receive a small commission if you purchase using them. A percent of all monies earned goes to help pay for this website and giveaways hosted by me .
    Click here to read the 
    Privacy Policy for Shelf Addiction


    Categories

    All
    1 Bookmark
    2 Bookmarks
    3 Bookmarks
    4 Bookmarks
    5 Bookmarks
    Aa Fiction
    Armchair Bea
    Audiobook
    Author Features
    Autobiography
    Biography
    Blog Tours
    Book Conventions
    Book Haul Tuesday
    Bookish Bargains
    Bookish News
    Bookish Pod Chat
    Book To Movie Adaptations
    Book To TV Adaptations
    BookTube Weekly
    Buddy Reads
    Chick Lit
    Christian Fiction
    Contemporary Fiction
    Contemporary Romance
    Cover Reveal
    Dystopian
    Erotica
    Fantasy
    Fantasy Series
    Feature & Follow Friday
    General Fiction
    Giveaways
    Guest Posts
    Historical Fiction
    Horror
    Inspirational
    Literacy Events
    Memoir
    Movie Reviews
    Mystery
    Narrator Interviews
    New Adult
    Non Fiction
    Paranormal
    Paranormal Romance
    Pop Culture Sunday
    Read Along
    Read A Thon
    Romance
    Romantic Suspense
    RTU
    Sa-book-club
    Saturday Book Chat
    Science Fiction
    Seasonal Reading
    Shelf Byte
    Short Stories
    Steampunk
    Summer Of Indie
    Suspense
    TBR Jar
    The Book Exchange
    The Recap!
    Thriller
    Throwback Thursday
    TPCP
    Tv Show Reviews
    Urban Fantasy
    Why I Love Wednesdays
    Womens Fiction
    Ya Dystopian
    Ya Fantasy
    Ya Fiction
    Ya Historical Fantasy
    Ya Historical Fiction
    Ya Mystery
    Ya Paranormal
    Ya Retelling
    Ya Romance
    Ya Science Fiction
    Ya Steampunk
    Ya Thriller
    Ya Urban Fantasy

    Reviews Published

    Sponsor Love

    Picture
    Advertise on 
    ​Shelf Addiction!

    Picture
    Picture
    We can't do this without you!! Support this podcast! Use the referral links, leave a review on your platform of choice, donate a coffee or checkout the merch store. Even show your support on Patreon!

    Podcast Book Chats, Bookish Topics, Book Reviews, Audiobook Reviews, Author and Narrator Interviews, Online Book Club

© 2012-2023 shelfaddiction.com. All rights reserved.