Shelf Addiction
  • Home
  • The Podcast
  • Blog
  • Monthly Read-Alongs
  • About Shelf Addiction
    • Media Kit
    • Advertising
    • Privacy Policy
  • Support Us
  • Shop
  • Tee Public Merch Store
  • Book Club Guide
  • Giveaways
Sign up for the FREE Shelf Addiction Newsletter!

BTMA Movie Review | The Girl on the Train

10/9/2016

5 Comments

 
Picture
What's BTMA? It stands for "book to movie adaptation". My BTMA reviews are done separately from the book review.

Movie Release Date: October 7, 2016
MPAA Rating: R | Mystery, Thriller | 1 hr 52 min
Watch Date: October 9, 2016
Rating: 3/5

This review is spoiler free, so if you haven't read the book or seen the movie yet, no worries, I've got you covered! 

Picture

​Curious to see what I thought about the book? Click here to read my book review of The Girl on the Train, which also earned a rating of 3/5.

This past weekend I took some time out to view the latest book to movie adaptation, The Girl on the Train. This book was constantly being compared to Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn. I don't think the book, nor the movie was good enough to earn that status.  While it's good, don't be fooled, this is no Gone Girl.
Picture
Picture
When I first starting seeing the trailers, I was excited and I hoped that the movie would thrive where the book fell short. Did that happen? No, not really.

I enjoyed the movie, but I tend to think it's because I read the book and felt vested, plus I already knew what was going on. Which I believe added to the viewing experience. I took my husband with me and his feedback was that the story felt jumbled up at times. I tend to agree. I think that for those that have not read the book, how the story unfolds could be a bit murky. 
The book is told in the first-person by each of the three women, but I'm not sure that translated well on film. Same as in the book, not only are we switching POV's between the three women this story centers around, but we are also switching from past to present quite frequently.  If not done cleanly, it could make the viewer frustrated.

​I enjoyed the fact that the film came very close to the book. It's rare for an adaptation to be so similar. I give them a thumbs up in that regard.  They also selected the cast well.  The first and most obvious change was the location. I was wondering if they would bring this story from the UK to the US and they did. The focal city went from London to NYC. What that a good change? Honestly, it made no impact either way.

Even though there was some issue with the progression of the time like, I liked the pacing. It kept my attention the entire movie. Rachel (Emily Blunt) is portrayed in such a true way, it's scary and sad all at once.  Her from her alcoholism to her total gullibility when it comes to her ex husband Tom (Justin Theroux) is genuine and I bought it. Emily Blunt was the star of the show and she nailed it.

I also enjoyed the simplification of the secondary characters (like Rachel's roommate) - with so much going on, we didn't really need to get into that like we did in the book.

Overall, while no where near perfect, I enjoyed it.  If you read the book, I totally recommend that you catch this one. It's definitely matinee worthy, and maybe even worth an evening movie date.  If you saw The Girl on the Train, please share your thoughts in the comments. I'd like to know if this was a hit or miss for you.
5 Comments
Classy Green
10/11/2016 01:09:36 pm

Hi Tamara. I saw the movie last weekend and I would have to agree with your 3 out of 5 stars. I thought the place was very slow. I fell asleep a little bit but I usually fall asleep at movies because the lights are off and it's cool. I think they did job casting the characters and staying true to the story. I would have liked to see more of the detectives involvement in the movie which I believe would have helped with the suspense and credibility or not of Rachel. I would watch the movie again because of the parts I missed while sleeping (lol) & because I am re-reading this book for Book Club. I am enjoying the book more the 2nd time around and have a better appreciation for Ms. Hawkins writing. I missed a lot of key points the first time around.

Reply
Liz @ Books I Think You Should Read link
10/11/2016 01:51:41 pm

Oh good! I'm hoping to see it next weekend sometime. Interesting that they moved it from London to NYC too. I really liked the book.

Reply
Crystal Wachoski link
10/12/2016 07:43:27 am

I read the book. I think I will wait to rent it after I read your review. Thanks!

Reply
Ron Leyba
10/12/2016 11:03:57 am

I really love watching these kinds of films. Will definitely see this one pretty soon!

Reply
Angela Sherman link
10/12/2016 09:51:44 pm

I actually really liked this book. I'm looking forward to the movie.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Gain access to exclusive content!
    Picture
    Click for Shelf Addiction merch!
    Follow on Bloglovin

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Get ONE month FREE!

    ​Rating Scale: 

    Picture
    Wonderful! Loved it! Add it to your shelf!
    Picture
    ​Very good read! It's bookshelf worthy.
    Picture
    ​I liked it. Borrow it from the library or a friend.
    Picture
    I got through it...barely! If you must read it, borrow it.
    Picture
    Don't waste your time.

    Picture

    Currently Reading

    Somebody I Used to Know
    Hidden Bodies

    Follow on Bloglovin

    Read the Printed Word!
    Picture

    DISCLAIMER 
    All affiliate links used on this site are links which I will receive a small commission if you purchase using them. A percent of all monies earned goes to help pay for this website and giveaways hosted by me .
    Click here to read the 
    Privacy Policy for Shelf Addiction


    Categories

    All
    1 Bookmark
    2 Bookmarks
    3 Bookmarks
    4 Bookmarks
    5 Bookmarks
    Aa Fiction
    Armchair Bea
    Audiobook
    Author Features
    Autobiography
    Biography
    Blog Tours
    Book Conventions
    Book Haul Tuesday
    Bookish Bargains
    Bookish News
    Bookish Pod Chat
    Book To Movie Adaptations
    Book To TV Adaptations
    BookTube Weekly
    Buddy Reads
    Chick Lit
    Christian Fiction
    Contemporary Fiction
    Contemporary Romance
    Cover Reveal
    Dystopian
    Erotica
    Fantasy
    Fantasy Series
    Feature & Follow Friday
    General Fiction
    Giveaways
    Guest Posts
    Historical Fiction
    Horror
    Inspirational
    Literacy Events
    Memoir
    Movie Reviews
    Mystery
    Narrator Interviews
    New Adult
    Non Fiction
    Paranormal
    Paranormal Romance
    Pop Culture Sunday
    Read Along
    Read A Thon
    Romance
    Romantic Suspense
    RTU
    Sa-book-club
    Saturday Book Chat
    Science Fiction
    Seasonal Reading
    Shelf Byte
    Short Stories
    Steampunk
    Summer Of Indie
    Suspense
    TBR Jar
    The Book Exchange
    The Recap!
    Thriller
    Throwback Thursday
    TPCP
    Tv Show Reviews
    Urban Fantasy
    Why I Love Wednesdays
    Womens Fiction
    Ya Dystopian
    Ya Fantasy
    Ya Fiction
    Ya Historical Fantasy
    Ya Historical Fiction
    Ya Mystery
    Ya Paranormal
    Ya Retelling
    Ya Romance
    Ya Science Fiction
    Ya Steampunk
    Ya Thriller
    Ya Urban Fantasy

    Reviews Published

    Sponsor Love

    Picture
    Advertise on 
    ​Shelf Addiction!

    Picture
    Picture
    We can't do this without you!! Support this podcast! Use the referral links, leave a review on your platform of choice, donate a coffee or checkout the merch store. Even show your support on Patreon!

    Podcast Book Chats, Bookish Topics, Book Reviews, Audiobook Reviews, Author and Narrator Interviews, Online Book Club

© 2012-2023 shelfaddiction.com. All rights reserved.